Krotos Audio's New AI Plugin Has Sound Designers Divided

What the Plugin Actually Does

Krotos Video to Sound is a plugin that runs inside Adobe Premiere Pro through the UXP Plugins panel. Editors select an in and out point on the timeline, choose a sound style, and hit Analyse and Render. The plugin then places synced sound effects automatically without the editor needing to leave the cut.

At launch, it covers six sound element categories: ambiences, whooshes, transitions, risers, impacts and cloth. Footsteps and spot effects are in development and are expected to arrive as a free update for existing subscribers.

Krotos is at pains to point out that the AI is assistive, not generative. Every sound in the system was recorded by professional sound designers and drawn from a library of over 100,000 recordings. The AI selects, combines and places those sounds; it does not synthesise them. The company has also stated it does not use customer video or audio to train its models.

The plugin is part of Krotos Studio, which also runs as a standalone app and as a VST, AU and AAX plugin inside a DAW. All versions are included across paid subscription tiers.

What Krotos SaysWhat Professionals SayAI-assisted, not generativeStill displaces human judgment at the placement stageProfessional sound without specialist knowledgeContradictory: you cannot have both at onceSpeeds up early stages for sound designersRemoves the entry-level work that trains new editorsDoes not use customer audio to train AISome remain sceptical of this claimFootsteps and spot effects coming soonExpanding coverage only increases the threat

"A Complete Backstab"

The announcement has landed badly in professional circles. On Facebook, the response ranged from disappointed to outright hostile.

Sound editor Michael Moeding laid out why: "Once we get AI scanning video and relating that to automatically making placements, that's where sound editors will start being impacted. This is where it begins. And Krotos is the first offender. For things like unscripted shows this kind of tech will certainly reduce the amount of time needed to get basic placements going, possibly reducing the amount of staffing requirements for junior and assistant level jobs at post houses."

Re-recording mixer Rico Casazza put it bluntly: "The real issue is that Krotos is actively courting picture editorial to bypass the sound department entirely. This type of generic automation completely misunderstands the art of post-production. Sound design isn't just about fast placement or ticking a box; it requires taste, human judgment, and unique intent. Krotos built its name on our community, and pitching a 'no specialist audio knowledge required' tool inside Premiere is a complete backstab to the professionals who supported them."

Sound designer James Wasserman, who said he regretted buying a Krotos bundle last year, called the marketing framing "incredibly disingenuous." The fact that Krotos positioned the tool as also being useful for professional sound designers did not go down well.

Sam Hayward kept it short: "If you're using AI for simple tasks, AI is using you to learn complex tasks."

The Quality Debate

Not everyone is convinced the current version even warrants this level of alarm. Several people questioned whether Krotos has shipped something that works well enough to threaten anyone yet.

Marius Paulikas, who had access to the beta, was sceptical: "I tried it, it was utterly useless junk. Unless they pulled a miracle in these past few months, this is going to be a dud."

Sound designer Mikko Roisko spotted a contradiction in the marketing copy itself. Krotos describes the tool as suitable for "video editors who want professional sound without specialist audio knowledge" and simultaneously for "sound designers looking to accelerate the repetitive early stages of a sound pass." His response: "I'm confused, does it produce 'professional sound' or just help with preliminary cutting in early stages?"

On Reddit's r/sounddesign, commenters were less charitable still. One noted that the plugin currently only covers ambiences in practice. Another described the AI's video matching as inconsistent and "all over the place."

"It Will Get Better. That's the Point."

The more measured voices in the debate acknowledge the plugin's current limitations. But they are not reassured by them.

Andres Boulton: "This is not going to replace us. Yet. It's not great, far from it. Not yet. But it's getting better. And for some clients, it doesn't have to be amazing, just good enough. And when that happens, a trend will start and many of us will end up competing fiercely for the few better gigs."

A longer thread on r/sounddesign made the structural argument clearly. The concern is not whether the tool can replace experienced sound designers on premium productions. It probably cannot. The concern is the entry-level work. The corporate videos, the low-budget unscripted projects, the quick-turnaround content where clients never cared much about sound quality to begin with. That is exactly where tools like this are already capable enough to do the job. And those projects have historically been the entry point for people building careers in audio post.

Steven Ghouti put it plainly: "People working in corporate films, or stuff like that, will say 'it's good enough for me,' albeit being shit, and that takes an opportunity away for someone to work on it. And it's a totally back-stabbing action to take from that company, after having taken the cash of so many sound people to get where they are."

Post sound veteran Rob van Schoonderwalt added context from inside the industry: "More and more producers couldn't care less. 'People at home don't hear the difference anyway,' I kept hearing. The time when makers in broadcast really cared about good audio is long gone."

Where Krotos Actually Stands

Krotos is not a new name in audio post. The company built its reputation on tools used in major productions including Game of Thrones, Stranger Things and Star Trek. That history is exactly why the community response has been so sharp. Professionals who bought Krotos plugins, who helped build the brand's credibility, feel the company is now using that credibility to sell past them to a different market entirely.

Nick Granville-Fall said it directly: "I think since most of the audio community doesn't use them they are pivoting their software to editors. 'You don't have to leave Premiere,' that says it all. Don't bother sending the project to a sound specialist."

Not every voice is negative. Sound editor Grant Floering offered a different frame: "Could it place footsteps faster than a human? Sure. And I'll gladly use it as a tool when it makes sense. But a tool isn't a replacement for taste, creativity, or judgment. I might use it for sync, then replace, blend, or completely redesign what it generates. Don't fear the tools at hand."

Re-recording mixer Nathaniel Reichman questioned the emotional register of the debate: "We're the industry that adopted sound automation, ADR, green screens, drum machines, CGI and LED volumes. Why are we drawing a line here? I don't care what tools the SFX editor uses. I need that person to deliver a killer, well-organised set of tracks."

Fair points. But they sidestep what is actually bothering most of the people in this conversation. The debate is not about whether the tool can do the job of a senior sound designer. It is about whether a sufficient number of clients will decide it can do the job of anyone at all.

What Comes Next

Krotos has said footsteps and spot effects are coming as free updates, and that support for editors beyond Premiere Pro is planned. The plugin is free to try and included across Studio, Pro and Max subscription tiers.

The real question is what this looks like in two or three years, once the tool has improved and more competitors have followed. The concern is not AI reaching some philosophical threshold of creativity. It is AI getting good enough for clients who never cared about quality in the first place.

That bar is lower than most people want to admit.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Krotos Video to Sound?

Krotos Video to Sound is an AI-assisted sound placement tool that analyses a region of video footage and automatically places synced sound effects from a library of over 100,000 professionally recorded sounds. It runs as a native plugin inside Adobe Premiere Pro through the UXP Plugins panel, and is also available as a standalone application and as a VST, AU and AAX plugin inside a DAW.

Does Krotos Video to Sound use generative AI?

No. Krotos has been clear that the tool is AI-assisted rather than generative. The AI selects, combines and places sound effects, but every sound in the library was recorded and refined by professional sound designers. Krotos states it does not use customer video or audio to train its AI models.

What sound element types does the Premiere Pro plugin support at launch?

At launch, the plugin covers six categories: ambiences, whooshes, transitions, risers, impacts and cloth. Footsteps and spot effects are currently in development and are expected to be added to the plugin at no extra cost for subscribers.

Why are sound designers angry about the Krotos Premiere Pro plugin?

The community anger centres on two things. First, Krotos built its name selling tools to professional sound designers and now appears to be pivoting toward a non-specialist market, which many see as a betrayal. Second, there is a structural concern that tools like this will erode entry-level positions in audio post production, removing the starting rung on the career ladder for new editors even if they leave experienced professionals largely unaffected.

Will Krotos Video to Sound replace professional sound designers?

For high-budget productions that require creative sound design, the current consensus is no. But the concern in professional circles is not about replacement at the top. It is about the low-budget, fast-turnaround work that has historically served as the entry point for people starting careers in audio post. That category of work is exactly where tools like this are already capable enough to satisfy clients who prioritise speed and cost over quality.

Is the Krotos Video to Sound plugin any good?

Early feedback from professionals who used the beta is mixed to negative. Several described the output as inconsistent and limited. The plugin currently covers a narrow range of sound elements and critics have noted the AI's placement logic lacks creative intent. However, most commenters acknowledge that the quality will improve over time, which is the root of the concern rather than the current output.

How is Krotos Video to Sound priced?

The plugin is free to try and is included across Krotos Studio's paid subscription tiers (Studio, Pro and Max). Higher tiers include greater usage allowances. It is part of the wider Krotos Studio platform, which also includes a standalone application and DAW plugin versions.

What This Means

What happens to Krotos from here depends partly on whether the community backlash has any real commercial weight. Several professionals have publicly stated they are done with the company. Whether that translates to meaningful revenue loss, or whether Krotos has already calculated that its future lies with a different audience entirely, remains to be seen.

For sound professionals, the craft still matters. Intentional, creative sound design for picture is not something a first-pass placement tool can replicate. But the entry-level market is a different story. And that is a conversation the industry needs to have, loudly, before the moment has already passed.

Browse our library of professionally recorded sound effects at 344 SFX, designed by practitioners for practitioners.